That's a nice climate bill you've got there. But can it pass?
That’s a nice climate bill you’ve got there. But can it pass?
Jul 29, 2022
Issue: Climate Change
After an initial wave of surprise and positive reactions to the unexpected climate bill debuted Wednesday night by Senators Joe Manchin and Chuck Schumer, the country’s attention has turned to whether or not Schumer can get the bill to President Biden’s desk before the Senate breaks for an August recess.
First of all, the bill has to get through the referee of the Senate, known as the parliamentarian. That’s because Schumer is hoping to pass the bill through a process known as reconciliation, which allows Democrats to bypass a Republican filibuster and pass legislation on a 50-50 vote (with Vice President Kamala Harris breaking the tie). But reconciliation also requires that everything in the bill be budget-related, and Republican senators are apparently already preparing parliamentary challenges to individual parts of the act. The nonpartisan parliamentarian will go through and decide what can stay in before it heads to the full Senate for a vote.
Next, Schumer has to get every Democrat in the Senate on board—and physically onto the Senate floor—which could be challenging, given that a few members are out with COVID-19 and Arizona Senator Kyrsten Sinema has been almost entirely silent on the bill. Her office told reporters she’s waiting to see what comes out of the parliamentarian process before she decides whether she’ll support it. Since all Republican senators are expected to vote against the package, Sinema must vote yes for it to pass.
And of course, after passing the Senate, the bill has to go through the House, where progressive Democrats could find fault with the bill on grounds that it locks in fossil fuel development or doesn’t go far enough to address climate change. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, perhaps the most well-known progressive Democrat in the House, has indicated she will likely support the package.
“I think it is an overwhelmingly positive development,” she said, adding the “progress on climate far outweighs some of the negatives.”
Finally, Manchin’s support for the bill could also falter if anything happens to derail a “side deal” on permitting reform. The deal would apparently speed permitting for infrastructure on federal lands, including renewable and fossil fuel projects as well as transmission lines. While no details of that plan have been released, Manchin’s vote on the climate bill is contingent on Congress passing it. So far, Democrats seem to be willing to pass some kind of reform to secure Manchin’s vote on climate, but members like Rep. Raúl Grijalva, who chairs the House Natural Resources Committee, say they want details on the permitting bill before they commit to supporting it.
So what happens if the climate bill doesn’t pass?
Evergreen Action chief of staff Lena Moffitt answers that question in a new episode of CWP’s podcast, The Landscape. Moffitt discusses what President Biden can do through executive action to fight climate change, including a major overhaul of the public lands oil and gas leasing system. And even if the legislation does pass, Biden will still need to use his power to take more steps if he wants to reach his own goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 50 to 52 percent by 2030.
Quick hits
At Yosemite, saving some trees means cutting others down
Methane is responsible for 25% of today’s global warming, and we can’t limit future warming to two degrees Celsius if we don’t drastically cut those emissions… We have the tools to cut methane in half and the faster we do that, the better off our climate and communities will be.”
—Ilissa Ocko, a senior climate scientist at the Environmental Defense Fund, Associated Press
Under the midnight sun, Kenai National Wildlife Refuge offers diverse outdoor recreation options. Alaska’s most-visited refuge is nearly two million acres in size, with world-class fishing, camping and hiking opportunities at lakes and rivers fed by meltwater from Skilak Glacier.
(featured image: The climate bill includes major funding for wind energy incentives; Z22, Wikimedia Commons)
Each day, the Center for Western Priorities compiles the best of Western public lands and energy development news. Take a look at our recent newsletters, and sign up here.
On Tuesday, the Biden administration revoked a land-exchange deal made during the Trump administration that would have allowed a road to be built through the Izembek National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska. Interior Secretary Deb Haaland said in a statement that the department would begin a new process to review previous land exchange proposals, leaving the door open for another land […]
The Biden administration is proposing a new permitting program to address the issue of wind turbines killing bald and golden eagles, without slowing down the construction of new wind energy projects. Bald eagle numbers have quadrupled since 2009 to about 350,000 birds, but there are only about about 40,000 golden eagles left. The proposal, which comes after several major utilities […]
A new post from the Center for Western Priorities breaks down what the Inflation Reduction Act would mean for the oil and gas leasing system on public lands, what the challenges are for the bill to pass, and how President Biden could act on climate if it doesn’t. The bill makes unprecedented investments in fighting climate change as well as major reforms to the […]
DENVER—The unprecedented climate agreement reached tonight as part of the broader budget reconciliation process includes significant measures to reduce America’s carbon emissions, including major reforms to the federal onshore oil and gas leasing program. The Center for Western Priorities released the following statement from Executive Director Jennifer Rokala: “This bill includes the first meaningful reforms […]
Methane is responsible for 25% of today’s global warming, and we can’t limit future warming to two degrees Celsius if we don’t drastically cut those emissions… We have the tools to cut methane in half and the faster we do that, the better off our climate and communities will be.”