A federal appeals court upheld a ruling that blocks a proposed mile-wide open pit copper mine near Tucson, Arizona. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals said that while Rosemont Copper has a valid mining claim to the minerals, it cannot use that claim to dump an estimated 1.9 billion tons of waste on adjacent forest service land.
Judge William Fletcher wrote that the general mining law of 1872 only gives companies the right to use land where valuable minerals have been found—which is not the case for the mine’s proposed waste site.
Attorney Heidi McIntosh with Earthjustice, which represented mine opponents, explained that the ruling exposed the limits of the 150-year-old law that still governs hard rock mining in America today.
“What Congress did at the time was to give prospectors who were willing to go out there and try to develop mines a certain amount of land,’’ McIntosh said.
“At the time, they contemplated that miners would go out and do an 1872-size mine and that the lands they would get to do that would be enough to store any kind of waste or tailings that they generated. Of course, if you’re talking about a mile-wide pit that Rosemont is, they’ve just kind of outgrown the mining law.”
Bill would help coal communities transition
Senator Michael Bennet of Colorado introduced a bill to support communities as the country transitions away from coal power. The National Energy Community Transition Act would create a $20 billion endowment to pay for core services and transition grants to diversify coal-dependent local economies. Leasing revenue from fossil fuel and renewable energy projects would contribute to a second account.
The Steamboat Pilot highlights the town of Hayden, Colorado, where a $22 million school bond measure passed in 2017. The bond is 55% dependent on Hayden Station, a coal-fired power plant that is scheduled to shut down by the end of 2028.
Quick hits
See the Western conservation projects getting Infrastructure Act money this year
This landmark decision further validates that Rosemont’s foreign owners have neither the legal right nor the valid mining claims for their proposed plan to destroy sacred sites beneath a mountain of poisonous mine waste. The ruling thoroughly dismantles the error-riddled process and reinforces the importance of protecting these sites and the entire region’s water supply. As decisive as this decision is, Rosemont’s foreign investors will likely continue to try and profit through environmental and cultural destruction. We must not allow this to happen.”
—Tohono O’odham Nation Chairman Ned Norris, Jr., Courthouse News
Coastal brown bear females are fierce protectors of their young, especially their “cubs of the year.” Cubs born in the den in January or February emerge with their mothers in May and June to romp about and learn life skills for survival in the bear world.
This bear family lives along the Joshua Green River at Izembek National Wildlife Refuge, a Wilderness watershed system famous for large coastal brown bears, that feeds into the great wetlands of Izembek and Moffet lagoons.
Photo: Mary Frische and Tom Collopy for USFWS.
(featured image: A computer rendering of the proposed open pit mine and tailings piles, Hudbay Minerals)
Each day, the Center for Western Priorities compiles the best of Western public lands and energy development news. Take a look at our recent newsletters, and sign up here.
Lisbon Valley Mining is seeking permission to expand an open-pit copper mine and other operations on more than 1,000 acres of national public land in southeast Utah, worrying local ranchers and residents. The company has asked the Environmental Protection Agency for an exemption in order to inject chemicals into the the Burro Canyon aquifer, which locals rely on for both drinking […]
Kate and Aaron are joined by Jimmy Tobias, a public lands reporter and contributor to the Public Domain substack, and Jacob Malcom, former Deputy Assistant Secretary for Policy and Environmental Management at the Interior Department, to talk about Elon Musk’s attacks on the Interior Department and its employees. Jimmy has been covering changes inside Interior […]
Department of the Interior officials attended a community meeting Friday to gather feedback on the proposal to designate Chuckwalla National Monument, signaling that the administration is interested in moving forward with a monument designation. Attendees included BLM Director Tracy Stone-Manning and Acting Deputy Interior Secretary Laura Daniel-Davis. An estimated 700 people attended the meeting, and […]
The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) released its final Oil and Gas Rule last Friday, bringing forth long-overdue updates to the regulations governing onshore oil and gas development on national public lands. The Biden administration inherited a federal oil and gas program that was broken and rigged in favor of the oil and gas industry. In August 2022, Congress passed the Inflation Reduction Act […]
This landmark decision further validates that Rosemont’s foreign owners have neither the legal right nor the valid mining claims for their proposed plan to destroy sacred sites beneath a mountain of poisonous mine waste. The ruling thoroughly dismantles the error-riddled process and reinforces the importance of protecting these sites and the entire region’s water supply. As decisive as this decision is, Rosemont’s foreign investors will likely continue to try and profit through environmental and cultural destruction. We must not allow this to happen.”